Banned Books #4 Go Ask Alice

banned books

Every month for the rest of 2014, ChrissiReads, Bibliobeth & Luna’s Little Librarywill be reading one Banned / Challenged Book a month. We’ll be looking at why the book was challenged, how/if things have changed since the book was originally published and what we actually think of the book.

This month’s choice is Go Ask Alice by ‘Anonymous’

11391020

First published: 1971
Most recently in the Top Ten of Frequently Challenged Books in 2003 & 2001 (source)
Chosen by: ChrissiReads
Reasons: drugs (2003) & offensive language, sexually explicit (2001)
*******

Do you understand or agree with any of the reasons for the book being challenged when it was originally published?

BETH: When I first began this read, I was quite surprised to learn that it was first published in 1971 as I found it read more contemporary than that – in other words, published about ten years ago or so. For the seventies, I think it was probably highly controversial when it came out even with the amount of “free love,” that was floating around at the time. I didn’t really find the language particularly offensive or find that it was sexually explicit but I am probably judging it by modern standards!

CHRISSI: I think it was probably very controversial at the time, so of course, it didn’t fit in. I don’t think it’s necessarily a bad thing that this book stood out, but I can understand why it was banned. The subject matter obviously struck a chord with many people.

LUNA: I honestly don’t know, 1971 is too long ago. My opinion of the 70s is mostly from That 70s Show that isn’t going to be an accurate reflection of the time is it? The book was published; it’s supposed to be warning regarding the dangers of drugs so it would have to be make an impact to work.

How about now?

BETH: This book deals with some very serious issues, namely teenage drug abuse. For this reason, I do understand why it is banned/challenged, especially in schools. I know that the book is meant to be quite gritty and portray a teenager coming out the other side of addiction but for me personally, I don’t think that message got across very well. At times I even felt like it glorified drug use in a way, or made it seem quite a lot of fun. Obviously that is not really a good message to send out to impressionable young people.

CHRISSI: I don’t really like that this book is marketed as non fiction. I actually thought it was a true story until I looked it further. It’s very frustrating that it’s marketed as non fiction when it’s not. Hmmmm. Non fiction or fiction aside, I don’t think it’s appropriate for use in schools. It raises very dark issues (as well as the drug use) which I don’t think are appropriate for some impressionable teenagers. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying that every teenager is impressionable (they’re certainly not!), but some may take the messages this book sends in the wrong way.

LUNA: It’ll come as a surprise but I have a problem with this book. It’s nothing to do with the content (the banned reasons: drugs, offensive language and sexually explicit) and everything to do with the marketing. Go Ask Alice is a work of fiction. Yet it was originally promoted as nonfiction, it’s still sold as “by Anonymous” and the copy I have has “This is Alice’s True Story” on the cover plus the blurb on the back, the foreword and the Psychologist’s Comment at the back – everything is still packaged to make out this is nonfiction.It got my back up. It is fiction and it should be presented as such.

What did you think of the book?

BETH: I have to admit, I was really, really disappointed. It’s only a short read (162 pages in my copy) and is made up of journal entries but for me it felt like a slog to get through the whole time. The main character annoyed me to the point where I wanted to throw the book across the other side of the room! And worse of all, I just didn’t believe it. Then we come to the ending… and for a second I almost upgraded my thoughts to a “three star” review until I read a bit more about the book in general. And I’m absolutely disgusted. As the girls have said, this is marketed as a work of non-fiction and if you buy into that the ending may change the way you feel about the entire book. As I later found out, it is a work of FICTION and I don’t know what else to say except that I feel really cheated and quite cross.

CHRISSI: It wasn’t what I thought it was going to be if I’m honest. I wanted to feel connected to the main character and feel sorry for her. But I didn’t. I just found her annoying- which isn’t what I wanted to feel from a teenage drug addict.

LUNA: The narrator is not likeable; I didn’t have any connection with her and found her rather whiny. Given that the point of this book if to warn of ‘what can happen’ I would have expected more empathy with the character. (Btw it’s never established what her name is.) I know the book is over 40 years old but Go Ask Alice really feels it. A lot of the time I don’t notice age with books when I’m lost in a story but I don’t think the text has dated well. Maybe it’s partly to blame for the disconnect I felt to the character/story. I’ll admit that my opinion of Go Ask Alice was negatively influenced by the marketing before I started the book but I was hoping the content would win me round – it never really did.

Would you recommend it?

BETH: I think it’s important that teenagers get to read the real stories behind drug addiction (get it? REAL!) but I wouldn’t recommend this one. I’ll get off my soapbox now.

CHRISSI: Possibly, but I think there are more powerful books around the same subject out there.

LUNA: If it wasn’t still labelled as a “true story” maybe but I think there are better books out there.

Our next banned book is Annie on My Mind by Nancy Garden. Look out for it on the last Monday of November!

Advertisements

Stacking The Shelves #88

Click on the image to take you to Tynga's blog to learn more! (Opens in same window)

Click on the image to take you to Tynga’s blog to learn more! (Opens in same window)

Stacking The Shelves is all about sharing the books you’re adding to your shelves, be it buying or borrowing. From ‘real’ books you’ve purchased, a book you’ve borrowed, a book you’ve been given or an e-book they can all be shared!

As ever, click on the book Image to get to the Goodreads page!

Bought:

11391020 Layout 1

I don’t have many books that have been added to my collection this week! I bought Go Ask Alice for part of my Banned Books feature with Luna and my sister Beth. I’m hoping to read it soon! Our views on Go Ask Alice will be out on the last Monday of October. I also picked up a copy of The Castle by Sophia Bennett, because it’s Sophia Bennett and I love her writing!

What have you added to your shelves this week? Please feel free to link me to your posts and I’ll stop by!

Top Ten Things On My Reading Wishlist

toptentuesday

Top Ten Tuesday is hosted by the lovely The Broke and The Bookish. Each week they come up with a list for us to complete. This week it is the Top Ten Things On My Reading Wishlist. By this they mean if you could make authors write about these things you would. It could be a specific type of character, an issue tackled, a time period, a certain plot, etc.

I’ve found this Top Ten list incredibly hard, so I’ve decided to highlight books that I want to read this year instead and why I’m wishing for them. I know, I know that’s cheating, but they’re on my reading wishlist… so I’m loosely following the topic! 😉

As ever, click on the book image to take you to the Goodread’s page for the book!

6931356

The DuffKody Keplinger– I’ve heard good things about this book.  I’ve never heard of the term ‘Duff’ being used, so I’m interested to see where this book goes.

11043618

What’s Left Of MeKat Zhang- I really like dystopian reads. I’m very intrigued by this book, having seen it highly recommended by bloggers that I adore!

11391020

Go Ask AliceAnonymous– The fact that the author has called themselves Anonymous intrigues me.  I know through linking it to Goodreads that the author has been revealed. This sounds like a particularly powerful book.

12576579

Night SchoolC.J Daugherty– So many people have read this book and loved it. I think I should definitely bump it up my wishlist!

13360957

PointeBrandy Colbert– I’ve mentioned it before on my blog, but I’ll mention it again. I LOVE books that include dance. I can’t dance myself, but I love watching it and reading about it. I need this book in my life!

15790870

Thousand WordsJennifer Brown– I’ve slowly been working my way through Jennifer Brown’s books. I love her writing. I enjoy reading books that deal with issues.

Panic_HC_JKT_des4.indd

PanicLauren Oliver– I was so disappointed by Requiem. I couldn’t finish it. I love Lauren Oliver’s writing, but my faith in her writing needs to be restored. Will this happen with Panic? I’ll have to read it to see!

18076780

Perfect RuinLauren Destefano– I can’t wait to begin another series by Lauren Destefano. I’m completely in love with her writing!

18298225

On The FenceKasie West– I am a bit of a fangirl of Kasie West’s books. I loved Pivot Point. I can’t wait for Split Second. I devoured The Distance Between Us so I need On The Fence!

15790873

This Is What Happy Looks LikeJennifer E.Smith- I’ve wanted to read this book for a long time now. I’m not sure what’s been holding me back.

So there it is my version of this week’s Top Ten list. I had to put my own spin on this week’s topic. Did you manage it though? What is on your reading wishlist? Please feel free to leave your links to your posts and I’ll stop by your blogs!